Time: 90 minutes Outcome: Students will build an evidence-based incident timeline, maintain competing hypotheses, and explain confidence without overstating what the logs prove.
Materials
- Sanitized fictional log set
- Timeline worksheet
- Competing-hypotheses table
- Markers or spreadsheet
Learning Objectives
- Normalize time and event data into a coherent timeline.
- Separate observation from interpretation.
- Maintain at least two plausible hypotheses while evidence is incomplete.
- State confidence and identify missing evidence.
Opening (10 minutes)
- Show three log entries and ask students to distinguish facts from assumptions.
Timeline Build (25 minutes)
- Teams normalize timestamps, order events, and mark gaps or conflicts.
- Every timeline entry must cite the source log or artifact.
Competing Hypotheses (20 minutes)
- Teams write at least two explanations for the observed sequence.
- For each hypothesis, identify supporting evidence, contradictory evidence, and unknowns.
Evidence Update (20 minutes)
- Release a second packet of fictional evidence.
- Teams update the timeline and confidence ratings without deleting the original reasoning trail.
Debrief (15 minutes)
- What changed your confidence?
- Which evidence was most discriminating?
- Where could confirmation bias have affected the team?
Evidence and Assessment
- Collect the timeline and hypothesis table. Assess source traceability, disciplined uncertainty, quality of competing explanations, and revision when new evidence appears.
Optional Companion
- Pair with “Sanitized Log Triage” from Labs & Activities for a longer lab-oriented version.

