Read, print, or adapt this practical performance rubric.
All educatorsRead online + download
Authorization and safety
4 - Independent and defensible
Confirms and follows scope, data, stop, and reporting controls
3 - Competent
Follows controls with minor prompting
2 - Developing
Misses or misunderstands a control
1 - Limited
Disregards essential controls
Score/notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Method
4 - Independent and defensible
Uses a logical, repeatable process and adapts to evidence
3 - Competent
Uses an appropriate process
2 - Developing
Process is incomplete or heavily prompted
1 - Limited
No coherent process
Score/notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Technical result
4 - Independent and defensible
Accurate, verified, and appropriate to the task
3 - Competent
Correct with minor errors
2 - Developing
Partial or weakly verified
1 - Limited
Incorrect or absent
Score/notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Evidence
4 - Independent and defensible
Relevant, protected, labeled, and sufficient
3 - Competent
Sufficient with minor omissions
2 - Developing
Incomplete or excessive
1 - Limited
Unreliable or absent
Score/notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Troubleshooting
4 - Independent and defensible
Tests hypotheses and recovers safely
3 - Competent
Resolves ordinary issues
2 - Developing
Uses unstructured changes
1 - Limited
Cannot recover or explain actions
Score/notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Communication
4 - Independent and defensible
Explains decision, consequence, limitation, and next action
3 - Competent
Communicates major reasoning
2 - Developing
Mostly descriptive or jargon-heavy
1 - Limited
Unclear or misleading
Score/notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Reflection
4 - Independent and defensible
Identifies specific improvement and transferable lesson
3 - Competent
Identifies useful lesson
2 - Developing
General reflection
1 - Limited
No meaningful reflection
Score/notes
Complete in the editable or printed copy.
Source and use
The Complete Cybersecurity Educator · Dr. Jason Edwards. Editable companion - Practical Performance Rubric.
Please do not resell this resource. You may repost or share it with other educators; keep the Bare Metal Cyber Educators Hub URL and source attribution intact. See the companion permissions. Use fictional or appropriately authorized material and follow the safety guidance in each resource.
Help improve the Educators Hub.Report a mistake, request a resource, or suggest an improvement.